Do you allow the appeal?

[GarthB]

Originally Posted by RPatrino

In OBR, according to J/R, this is a time play, no run counts as the runner touched the plate after the 3rd out was made. Now, Rick Roder offered a contradictory interp on this, and you would count this run.

Interesting. So Rick Roder, the "R" in J/R, disagrees with the J/R?

[justanotherblue]

How can you score a run when the third out has already been recorded? If the runner missed the plate, and immediatly returned to touch the dish after the third out he brings his efforts into a time play, hence no run. If he walks away, and prays it wasn't seen, he has a run until a proper appeal.

[Dave Reed]

Originally Posted by GarthB

Interesting. So Rick Roder, the "R" in J/R, disagrees with the J/R?

Not really. CC says so, but the "conflicting" opinion given by "R" is that a runner can return to touch home plate during a dead ball. Not really related to the OP situation, as far as I can see. CC's assertion in the 2004 BRD is in article 459, and CC gives a case play similar to OP that he says "R"'s ruling supports, but I don't see how.