Quote:
Originally Posted by LDUB
Do call live ball offsides fouls instead of dead ball encroachment also? It isn't your job to decide which fouls keep the ball from becoming live.
|
No, but the rules (and experience) do tell us which and why some things are fouls as soon as they happen and why some aren't fouls until they go uncorrected prior to the snap.
If the case book says you shut it down when you see it, I'm fine with that. We all know that the books say lots of things that we don't always do.
I'm just saying it's inconsistent given other fouls that we give A time to correct prior to the snap. "Wrong ball" is a 99.9 percenter. The play referenced in the OP doesn't rise to that level UNTIL there's a (deceptive) snap, IMHO and for the reasons I outlined above.
Overthinking? Fair enough.
Wed Oct 15, 2008, 01:34am
Similar Threads
Threaded Mode
