batting out of order 2

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by umpjong

This correct, my reply is only correct if there is a pitch to the third batter in OP, there was not so this, above, is correct...

If they throw a pitch to Able, then Baker's at bat is made proper and the next batter should be Charlie. But since Charlie is on base, the proper batter would be Danny.

If Able is at the plate, he gets to sit, and Danny comes to the plate and inherits Able's count (1-0 or 0-1 after one pitch). Nobody's out in this situation, and no runners are removed; the coach was 1 pitch too late to appeal BOO.

I think that's what you said.