Occupying the same base

[celebur]

Originally Posted by charliej47

F5 tags both R1 and R2 on 2nd base.

I have an out here as well, unless you wrote that incorrectly. 2 runners on the same base and both are tagged, then 1 of them has to be out. Though I do wonder what F5 was doing way over at 2B.

Originally Posted by charliej47

R1 and R2 both walk off the base. They both get tagged again while off the base. I call both of them out and the OC goes bananas.

One of them was already out. And as already stated, by not calling that out, you have placed the other in jeopardy, who likely would not have left the base.