Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantherdreams
I think we are just dealing with semantics here. Illegal = contrary to the rules.
Contact is judged as illegal based on rule and tower principle by us calling fouls, contact can violate the rules but be deemed incidental based on principles.
By definition of the word illegal, though the second an action is contrary to the statues/laws or contrary to rules and regulations it is illegal.
Splitting hairs at this point.
|
Not really. If choose to not call a foul, you have determined that the play was LEGAL in the context of the entire set of rules....including the advantage/disadvantage/incidental elements. The action could have been illegal if it had an effect on the play (RSBQ, for example) but if it doesn't, then it is not illegal.
Sat Jan 31, 2015, 09:50pm
Similar Threads
Threaded Mode
