What would you do?

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by jeffpea

sometimes officials "see" things that just are there...obviously, based on rockyroad's last post - we can now say that sometimes officials "read" things that just aren't there...

I did not use the word NEVER. My exact words were: "the C should not have a whistle on block/charge plays going to the basket"....while anyone can try to parse what that means...we all can agree that "NEVER" did not appear, correct?

Hard to stay on your feet while doing all that back-pedaling?

So A3 catches a pass on the wing on C's side...B is playing a 2-3 zone and has lost track of A3. There is no defender within 10 feet of him. A3 drives to the basket where B4 is standing and waiting - B4 has clearly established LGP. The expected crash ensues...you would have the C wait for the L to call this because in your blanket-statement world the C should not have a whistle on this type of play. Even though there was nothing else for the C to be looking at? Even though it is clearly on the C's side of the key?

Ok...if you say so.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by rockyroad

hard to stay on your feet while doing all that back-pedaling?

So a3 catches a pass on the wing on c's side...b is playing a 2-3 zone and has lost track of a3. There is no defender within 10 feet of him. A3 drives to the basket where b4 is standing and waiting - b4 has clearly established lgp. The expected crash ensues...you would have the c wait for the l to call this because in your blanket-statement world the c should not have a whistle on this type of play. Even though there was nothing else for the c to be looking at? Even though it is clearly on the c's side of the key?

Ok...if you say so.

+1,000