Crew Integrity

[Smitty]

Originally Posted by EndEx

the result was he unwittingly undermined his partner's authority.

I'm still not seeing this. Are you suggesting partner's shouldn't get together to discuss anything for fear it will "look bad"? Some coaches will try and use anything they can to try and get into the official's heads. That's just part of the game. I think it's overblowing it a bit to say that anyone's authority was undermined in this scenario.

[EndEx]

Good question, and no, I'm not saying they shouldn't try to get it right for fear of anything. If he had come over immediately, it wouldn't have "looked" bad. Instead, he stood opposite the table and let her flesh it out with the coach for a little bit and only came over to question her after it was clear the coach wasn't to let it go. It was at least 15 seconds after her initial call before the T came over to offer help.

He came over, blew his whistle for everyone to see, then had a 5 second discussion with her before turning around and heading back opposite.

It looked like the coach's argument made him, from across the court, question his partner's judgment.

Now, the coach was a d1ckhead anyway, so you're probably right; he would have found something else.

[Smitty]

But you're still just guessing about why he came over and what he said, so the leap to "undermining an official's authority" seems overblown to me. Perhaps it was poor timing, perhaps not. I'm only arguing that no one's authority was undermined based on what you know and how you painted it.

[johnnyrao]

Originally Posted by Smitty

But you're still just guessing about why he came over and what he said, so the leap to "undermining an official's authority" seems overblown to me. Perhaps it was poor timing, perhaps not. I'm only arguing that no one's authority was undermined based on what you know and how you painted it.

Smitty, completely concur with you. In fact, I was always taught that this is exactly the way it should be done. If a non-calling official feels he/she has information about the call, they come to you and tell you what they saw. If you say you saw it differently, they go back and play on. Seems to me like this crew did exaclty that. What I am confused about in the OP is where it says the other official came across and "questioned" the call of the C. Do you know for sure he "questioned" her call, or simply came and said, "Here's what I saw..." and then got what the C called and returned to the game? If anything, from what I read in the OP, the only thing that COULD have been done differently was that the non-calling official could have come over earlier, but he may have delayed since the C was having a conversation with the coach (HTBT on that one).

[Adam]

Agreed, normally I'd like to see the T come over immediately on this; but it's possible he wasn't looking when she signaled and didn't know what her call was.

[Smitty]

Or maybe he came over to help her get away from the coach as their conversation may have been lasting too long in his opinion. We just don't know, so to speculate and go so far as to call it undermining is just not fair.

[EndEx]

Originally Posted by Smitty

Or maybe he came over to help her get away from the coach as their conversation may have been lasting too long in his opinion. We just don't know, so to speculate and go so far as to call it undermining is just not fair.

I specifically stated his intent was not to undermine her; it was obvious to me he wanted to get the call right. It "looked" like the coach's continued questions made him ask her if she was sure of her call. Now that I think about it, you may be right, though.

Reviewing it in my head again, he may have used the quick conference as a way to confirm her call and get the ball back in play. My initial thought as I was watching was that she was allowing the coach way too much time to debate the call.

In the end, the chance of it appearing that way may well have been worth it to cut that conversation short.