players with 4 fouls

[OHBBREF]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

so the foul that puts the player at the greatest disadvantage is the one that I'm calling, whether it's a star player's second foul, a star player's fifth foul, or a bench warmer's foul.

You did not just say that!

After all of the wrangling back and forth over whether it is right or wrong to know if a player has three or four fouls - and it influencing your calls you just said that you were going to call the foul that puts the player (thereby the team) at the greatest disadvantage.

You sure you do not want to rephrase that - becuase if you disagree with the original premise IMO what you just wrote is worse.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by OHBBREF

After all of the wrangling back and forth over whether it is right or wrong to know if a player has three or four fouls - and it influencing your calls you just said that you were going to call the foul that puts the player (thereby the team) at the greatest disadvantage.

You misunderstood Billy's point. He is going to call a foul on whichever player caused the greatest disadvantage to the shooter, regardless of whether it is the fouling player's second foul or fifth foul.

[OHBBREF]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

You misunderstood Billy's point. He is going to call a foul on whichever player caused the greatest disadvantage to the shooter, regardless of whether it is the fouling player's second foul or fifth foul.

then I recind my interpretation, my only disagreement then is
I do try to do as my mentors tell me in order to advance to the levels that they work. it does seem to follow when I see my comments in reviews about game managment.