Backcourt violation?

[cmathews]

Originally Posted by SamIAm

The rule relieves you of judgement when a live ball that is not a try goes through the basket. It doesn't instruct you on what to do when it does not go through the basket. You have decided that fed meant it to apply when it does not go through the basket. Yet fed doesn't say that. You posted that fed doesn't want us to read mines. Yet, in essence, that is what you have done. You have read fed mines to include that was not included or written.

I didn't critize your interpretation, I only commented that your logic was faulty.

no my logic is that since you used to have to judge whether it was a try or not to score three points, and they said score it all the time, then anything thrown at your own basket is a try.