charge or not

[Kostja]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

From Kostja: "There is a philosophy (HS as I understood it) that a player control foul should be called regardless of the position of the defender"

Kostja: You understand it wrong. The defender cannot be out of bounds. This rule change was made a few years ago. Of course this change goes along with all the other rules regarding legal guarding postion.

Thanks for the clarification. I never even thought about someone "playing defense" out of bounds To me this looks just as weird as playing defense behind the backboard oder underneath the basket