Vid Request: Texas vs Oklahoma

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

What do you do if people ask for several plays in one thread? Part of this is member driven.

Peace

Well, for one, I think that too many are asked for in a "I didn't get a look at that and I'd just like to see it again" mode, and not in a "what can I learn from that" mode. So, I'd probably not put so many up. I do recognize that I'm probably in the minority on this.

Second, the responder can create separate threads and respond to the OP that they are posted (or not) and the original thread can be deleted (or will go away). Or, one thread for all requests and separate threads for each video.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Well, for one, I think that too many are asked for in a "I didn't get a look at that and I'd just like to see it again" mode, and not in a "what can I learn from that" mode. So, I'd probably not put so many up. I do recognize that I'm probably in the minority on this.

Second, the responder can create separate threads and respond to the OP that they are posted (or not) and the original thread can be deleted (or will go away). Or, one thread for all requests and separate threads for each video.

Well in this particular thread people asked about 2 plays in this game\. I posted them to keep things streamlined on some level. I thought we always did it that way. It might get confusing if we discuss the same game in different threads. But I will do what the moderators want me to do when I post up. I do not think there is a stated policy either way. It really makes little difference to me. I just know that when someone says something similar the moderators combine the threads.

I think problem is mostly solved if people just reference the play in question, but I can see the confusion.

If the moderators have some insight, I will do what they wish.

It really makes little difference to me in the long run.

Peace

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Well in this particular thread people asked about 2 plays in this game\. I posted them to keep things streamlined on some level. I thought we always did it that way. It might get confusing if we discuss the same game in different threads.

You are correct in that is the way it has always been done. And it has always been confusing once you get past the first couple of replies after the videos are posted. You have to parse back through the replies sometimes to see which play it is that is being discussed.

Personally, I don't think 2-3 plays form the same game generally have anything to do with each other. Most of the time, the plays and the issues are isolated to a single play.