Is that fair?

[dash_riprock]

Originally Posted by Rich Ives

And when does it cease being legal??

According to 6.03, when both feet are not within the lines of the box.

The only "guidance" we have is that when he hits the ball with one or both feet on the ground entirely out of the box it's illegally hit.

That "guidance" is for when the batter hits the ball, not when the batted ball hits him. The new rule defines legal position when he is hit with the ball (6.03). As written, according to the new rule, if the batter is hit by a batted ball and both feet are not within the lines of the box, he is out.

I am sure that is not what they meant, but that is what they wrote.