Whistle or not

[Stillblind]

Officials Manual pg 21 says to sound whistle when play is about to begin only following a charged time out an intermission or an unusual delay. Do any areas regularly sound whistle following a substitution?

[Terrapins Fan]

Sometimes, based on how long the substitution has taken.

[Rob1968]

I've been doing a lot of games with 1st and 2nd year officials this year, as we have quite a few new members in our assn. Our Assignor asked me to help with the on-court mentoring, by taking more Soph/JV games, to work with them. Last week, my partner, a 1st year official, was blowing his whistle every time he had a throw-in. I mentioned it to him at halftime, but he still couldn't break the habit.
When I told him that the NBA does that, and they have their reason(s), he was finally able to overcome the tendency.

[HokiePaul]

Not regularly. Most of the time it's, player in; player out; glance at partner(s); administer the throw in.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Stillblind

Officials Manual pg 21 says to sound whistle when play is about to begin only following a charged time out an intermission or an unusual delay. Do any areas regularly sound whistle following a substitution?

We whistle in every sub.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Rich

We whistle in every sub.

You whistle them in, but do you whistle again to resume play?

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Adam

You whistle them in, but do you whistle again to resume play?

Oh.

No, not unless there's an appreciable delay.

There's little consistency in this area on endline frontcourt throw-ins, though. Some whistle, some don't. It was downright bizarre when one of my partners over Christmas whistled and the head coach told him that it wasn't a proper mechanic and to please stop it because it throws off his players. I stayed out of that one.

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by Rich

Oh.

No, not unless there's an appreciable delay.

There's little consistency in this area on endline frontcourt throw-ins, though. Some whistle, some don't. It was downright bizarre when one of my partners over Christmas whistled and the head coach told him that it wasn't a proper mechanic and to please stop it because it throws off his players. I stayed out of that one.

Amusingly, the coach is correct for NFHS.

Originally Posted by Rich

it throws off his players

Uh, what?

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Amusingly, the coach is correct for NFHS.

I know, but claiming it throws off his players was utter nonsense. I found out later this coach was also a varsity-level official before he became a coach and he does stuff like this to try to work officials.

Same guy told me he'd send me the film after the FIRST foul we called, BTW. Good times.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Rich

Oh.

No, not unless there's an appreciable delay.

There's little consistency in this area on endline frontcourt throw-ins, though. Some whistle, some don't. It was downright bizarre when one of my partners over Christmas whistled and the head coach told him that it wasn't a proper mechanic and to please stop it because it throws off his players. I stayed out of that one.

Why would you whistle there?

[BryanV21]

Originally Posted by Rich

...Same guy told me he'd send me the film after the FIRST foul we called, BTW. Good times.

Sounds like grounds for a T. Not sure that I would, but I believe I read from somebody around here that they'd whack a coach for talking about doing something like this.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Adam

Why would you whistle there?

It's an NCAAW mechanic. SO, some do it in HS. It can be a signal to tell the T to raise his/her hand for the throw-in.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BryanV21

Sounds like grounds for a T. Not sure that I would, but I believe I read from somebody around here that they'd whack a coach for talking about doing something like this.

I hear lots of things from "somebody around here" that I wouldn't do.

A T in this instance is way over the top, imo.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Rich

It throws off his players.

Originally Posted by AremRed

Uh, what?

Easy to see how. When I'm supposed to sound my whistle, i.e., after a timeout, sometimes some of the offensive players will start their inbounds play, setting screens, V-cuts, etc. on the whistle, while others will wait for the inbounder to say, "Go", slap the ball, etc. That half second lag time can screw up a good inbounds play, but that's the fault of the players, and coaching staff, not the officials.