Which is the erroneous free throw?

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by snaqwells

then i'd say your 2nd free throw was the erroneous one; although i'd likely allow the coach to keep all three and simply not give the last free throw.

If you give him all 4, and he make the first two and misses the 2nd two, they lose a point, imo. This one would suck, imo.

+1

[FrankHtown]

I was under the impression that as long as the clock had not started, even though the ball became live when handed to the shooter, any CE can be corrected at that point. I would think the second free throw for the original foul was unmerited, and if made, should be taken off the score. The Technical fouls should have no bearing at all.

[NCAAREF]

Let's make it a little more interesting...if the criteria for a correctable error is Live-Dead-Live....then when the ball is given to the free thrower for the first FT it is live...once the FT is over it is dead...when handed to him for the second the ball is again live.....now what?

[jdw3018]

Originally Posted by NCAAREF

Let's make it a little more interesting...if the criteria for a correctable error is Live-Dead-Live....then when the ball is given to the free thrower for the first FT it is live...once the FT is over it is dead...when handed to him for the second the ball is again live.....now what?

Since the criteria also includes the clock properly starting before the Live-Dead-Live scenario, it wouldn't matter.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by NCAAREF

Let's make it a little more interesting...if the criteria for a correctable error is Live-Dead-Live....then when the ball is given to the free thrower for the first FT it is live...once the FT is over it is dead...when handed to him for the second the ball is again live.....now what?

But, that is NOT the criteria for a correctable error...the first live ball must also coincide with the clock running...and that doesn't occur during a FT.