Charge Or Block

[lamarr1958]

Originally Posted by Dad

He saw it or he didn't. Oh, how many times I've heard this and the person saying it is wrong because the call was right

What on earth is to and through? Sounds like a weird definition of how to call a PC. You have no idea what the calling official had. Maybe a cheap shot with an elbow. Our view on this play is complete garbage and looks like a no-call. Who knows what he saw.

I am not going to argue about a definition on how to call a player control foul that you may not have heard. A definition I have heard in many pre-games and I have also used in many. If I told you I heard it from both Kenny (During a talk we had he lives near me) and Tommy Mauer (In a camp I attended) would it still be weird? And I disagree with you about our view on this play is complete garbage. If this video was me at the trail making this call I would still disagree with it. That's all I have to say.

[bob jenkins]

"To and through" *used to be* a good guideline. I *think* that it's been cahnged so the "through" part isn't really required. It's more like "to and into the vertical space with enough contact to basue an advantage" -- but that isn't as mnemonic.

[Dad]

Originally Posted by lamarr1958

If I told you I heard it from both Kenny (During a talk we had he lives near me) and Tommy Mauer (In a camp I attended) would it still be weird?

Yes, and I would've called out either of them to explain it to me. Taken literally it's doing no good for me, so I'm guessing I just don't get it.