protest play???

[RadioBlue]

Originally Posted by yawetag

i have to disagree. The third out was assumed when the bu called br out. There was no reason for the defense to make a play on r2 at home.

If (and that's a big if) this situation happens on my field, we're putting r2 back on 3b. His scoring without a play being made was the bu's fault, not the defense.

+1

[bob jenkins]

Under FED rules, if a call is reversed, umpires are supposed to correct any other actions that result from the reversed call. In this case, that *could* include returning R2 to third.

There's no specific guidance under OBR, but the FED philosophy on this is generally seen as "more fair" in most youth groups / leagues.

[yawetag]

Originally Posted by RadioBlue

+1

Did you quote my actual quote or rewrite it? I find it odd that all of my uppercase letters (except the first letter in the sentence) was dropped; never seen that here.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by yawetag

Did you quote my actual quote or rewrite it? I find it odd that all of my uppercase letters (except the first letter in the sentence) was dropped; never seen that here.

It happens regularly, actually.