How should I have handled this

[ozzy6900]

Originally Posted by jwwashburn

SNIPPED

Did I do anything wrong?

I have been umpiring for 15+ years and the coaching thing is new to me.

Awaiting your comments....

Joe

No, you did nothing wrong here. You had two cases of obstruction that should have been called. Your umpires should have exhibited the same enthusiasm on the field to the game as they did in the parking lot!

Here's the problem. Interference and obstruction are both calls that require recognition and judgment before the rule can be enforced. You can protest the rule if not adhered to but the call is more judgment than anything else. You will find that many younger umpires do not properly recognize obstruction (as in your two plays) and therefore can not judge that it happened. Better training would be a help but that would have to come from their UIC, not you.

Next time you are on the field and you see this happen. I would ask for TIME and approach the umpire in a professional manner. You better ask for TIME because young umpires have a fit if you don't (unlike those of us that deal with the older crowd).

You "Excuse me, (name of umpire - not 'Blue') but I think that my runner was obstructed on that play. Did you happen to see the same thing?"

The umpire is going to give you an answer (hopefully equally professional) and you are going to live with the results. You say "Thank you" and go back to your box or dugout.

When it happens again, you do the same thing. Maybe these umpires will see a light bulb illuminate and get the idea. I would also suggest that you and the UIC discuss training the umpires better over a cup of "joe" - your treat!