Pitcher taking signals.

[CO ump]

Originally Posted by GarthB

Tee:

I have no argument with the original reason for, and intent of, the rule. I would agree that it is a non-issue. As I said earlier, I have never felt the need to enforce this rule.

I do, however, have issue with the rule being used to allow a deceptive pick-off move.

I agree as well on both counts.

I have seen, on more than one occasion, pitchers leaning in, seemingly taking their sign while straddling the rubber. Whether intending to deceive or not, it certainly can be.
IF I were to balk this, I would not refer to the taking signs on the rubber rule, rather if asked, would refer to simulating a pitch while not on the rubber.
However, if I were doing my preventive umpiring thing I would not refer to simulating a pitch, instead I would tell F1 he can't take his sign from F2 from off the rubber.