Still First Play by an Infielder...

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by mcrowder

Unless BR had also reached first before F4 threw the ball, this is still a TOP award, R1 to third.

I think you're responding to a different scenario. The second question was this: F5 bobbles, throws late to F4 at 2B where R1 is safe. F4 then relays to 1B but throws out of play.

This is no longer the 1st play by an infielder, so the award is 2 bases from time of throw. R1 (now R2 at TOT) is awarded home, and BR is awarded either 2B or 3B depending on whether he had acquired 1B at TOT.