Should You Lie To Fix A Missed Call?

[rmstone]

Its a judgement call, get the coach off the field and play ball...

I argued in the other post that a pulled foot can and should be reviewed with other umpire (if the FU desides to), because in honesty the plate ump has the best view of the foot and the base... but the TIMING of an out/safe play should never be reviewed with the plate umpire... so I don't think this falls under the "get it right"...

Tell him to stick with his call, its a judgement call...

"Oh my God! First we want to "discuss everything" then "get the call right". Now we want to know if we should lie to do it? The discussions latley have me wondering if there is a sudden swing from being umpires to being politicians! "

You take this way too seriously...