L serving, 3 player exchange

[gair-z]

NFHS:
I have refs on both sides of this... so would appreciate your take(s).

Rule 10.4.5.b - when serving, the libero is not required to leave the playing area or be out of the set for 1 rally/dead ball before replacing the incoming player in the right-back position.

The question is, CAN she leave the court during these replacements?

SITUATION, L on Team A in LB, Team A wins rally and rotates. L is replaced by #14 who goes to LF. L goes off in replacement zone and stands just off court. L then replaces #7 who was in RF and the next server.

Legal?

[Lcubed48]

My initial answer is yes. That is legal. Most times the L will simply take the ball to go serve while the new LF and the old RF both exit through the replacement zone. If I'm not correct, please let know. Your rule reference is correct as I see it.

[bob jenkins]

I also vote Yes -- as long as it doesn't cause a delay, and they get it done before R1 beckons for serve.

[pavbref]

From the PA state interp:

If the L went to the bench, she should not be allowed to replace the serving player without sitting out one completed rally. Also, use preventative officiating early in the season to teach the teams the proper procedure by allowing the change, but warn the teams that this is not the proper procedure.

[FMadera]

Originally Posted by pavbref

From the PA state interp:

If the L went to the bench, she should not be allowed to replace the serving player without sitting out one completed rally. Also, use preventative officiating early in the season to teach the teams the proper procedure by allowing the change, but warn the teams that this is not the proper procedure.

I understand that's the interpretation...but that's counter to the actual rule, which allows for two replacements during the same dead ball if the libero is going to be the next legal server, and I believe, permits (but does not require) the libero to stay on the court for both replacements.

[gair-z]

Originally Posted by FMadera

I understand that's the interpretation...but that's counter to the actual rule, which allows for two replacements during the same dead ball if the libero is going to be the next legal server, and I believe, permits (but does not require) the libero to stay on the court for both replacements.

Felix, this is the way i interpret it. It's 2 individual replacements which is allowed per 10.4.1.c.
10.4.5.b allows the player to stay on the court for both.

[Tony.oe4]

I also agree with Felix. The rule allows the libero to not leave the court on the double replacement but it does not keep a team from actually doing a double replacement. As stated, preventative officiating early in the season with the coach would speed this process up later in the season.