8U rules conundrum

[AtlUmpSteve]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

But my question is why are there umpires working these games?

I used to NOT provide umpires at 8U, but my customers really want/need it. Combination of justifying registration fees and redirecting disputes from the teams and parents to a neutral arbiter.

The best part, for me as an assignor, is that our youth slowpitch has dried up; leagues just don't make anymore. I can still redirect those unable (physically) or unwilling to work fastpitch to coach pitch 8U, and keep them working (while not tieing up an experienced umpire). I also use it to get some young teens some experience at game management, without putting them in "real" fastpitch.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve

I used to NOT provide umpires at 8U, but my customers really want/need it. Combination of justifying registration fees and redirecting disputes from the teams and parents to a neutral arbiter.

I understand the registration side, but what I have seen is more like the "want/need" was more "I don't want to do that", for one of two reasons: they don't want to be screamed at by other parents, or they believe it is beneath their social status, like some people consider working the concession stand.

8U do not need umpires, they need coaches. IMO, it is a waste of money, but to some parents it is worth it.

The best part, for me as an assignor, is that our youth slowpitch has dried up; leagues just don't make anymore. I can still redirect those unable (physically) or unwilling to work fastpitch to coach pitch 8U, and keep them working (while not tieing up an experienced umpire). I also use it to get some young teens some experience at game management, without putting them in "real" fastpitch.

Second point is regional in that a lot of areas just do not have enough umpires to use up such a valuable resource. Obviously, that is not the case everywhere, but I would rather see the parents get a work out in the field of umpiring which may help develop a better opinion of what its like to be on the field. Granted, this reasoning is greedy and self-serving, but I don't care.