check swing

[AtlUmpSteve]

Originally Posted by Steve M

OK, IF this is ASA or Fed ball, I am not going to my partner. My response is "Catcher, I had a great look at that one. There was no swing."
In college ball, I go to my partner & we have whatever my partner has.
If I'm the BU, you get whatever I saw every time you come to me.

In college, no option, we must go if asked. BU must make the call s/he saw; period. In ASA/NFHS, it is optional, but, I will not refuse just because I called it and no one ran; that is their problem, and their failure. If I know I saw every part, I might refuse, but, if there is any chance I might have not seen it all (and that is very likely if you track the ball all the way), then refusing to go for the checked swing help is just wrong, IMO.

As BU, if PU asks me after calling it a swing, it just doesn't matter what I think of the judgment. My response will be "I cannot rule on a called swing; that cannot be appealed to the base umpire".