Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Goodman
So then what's wrong with loss of down in any of those situations?
|
I would think "Loss of Down" should be automatic, after all the act of dumping a pass means the play the offense called failed, one way or the other, so why would even think of giving that down back. Rule wise, it is what it is, and that's the way it will bedealt with (until the rules makers decide to change it).
I believe, at the NFHS level, the Illegal pass is considered a running play, (NF: 10-3-1a) which eliminates the timing confusion.
The problem with allowed dumping (outside the tackle box) is that: 1. The offense
chose which type play to call. 2. The defense has to
respond to whatever is called. When the defense does it's job and prevents the offense from attempting a legal forward pass, why give the offense an
unearned opportunity to negate their own failure and the accomplishment of the defense, by simply dumping the ball. The NF rule also provides for enforcing the penalty from the end of the run (with an illegal pass, the spot of the pass) whether it's beyond, or behind, the LOS.