Block Charge play (Video)

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by stick

... And fwiw, I'm not debating or challenging anyones version of the call at all. ....

You watched the video and made this statement:

"Tough call to make. The replay does show the defender moving upon impact. The official made a god call afaict."

That's what's your were questioned about. Nobody asked you explain what the official the video was thinking.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by stick

LOL A true funny man you are. And fwiw, I'm not debating or challenging anyones version of the call at all. Only answering what I was asked. No need for you make it personal.

Personal? What was personal about what I said?

What you're doing is defending the indefensible.

[stick]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

Of course I have. Anybody official worth their salt has done that. You need to be your own worst critic.

With critics like you around that might not be possible.

[stick]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

If I were evaluating you and you called it a block I would have told you were wrong and to review the rule book and referee defense from now on.

MTD, Sr.

That's fine Mark and I appreciate your advice.

[stick]

[QUOTE=Camron Rust;923937]Personal? What was personal about what I said?

Explain what the intent of posting this was:

"You might as well claim he might have seen the defender punch him in the nose, pull his shorts down, and spit in his face."

[stick]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

You watched the video and made this statement:

"Tough call to make. The replay does show the defender moving upon impact. The official made a god call afaict."

That's what's your were questioned about. Nobody asked you explain what the official the video was thinking.

And I addressed that, but it's not my problem that it might not satisfy you. FWIW, I never stated what that official WAS thinking, there's no way anyone but him could say what that was. I only stated what he MIGHT have been thinking. And that was in response to a members question.
Now, I'll let you be last word lucy.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by stick

And I addressed that, but it's not my problem that it might not satisfy you. FWIW, I never stated what that official WAS thinking, there's no way anyone but him could say what that was. I only stated what he MIGHT have been thinking. And that was in response to a members question.
Now, I'll let you be last word lucy.

I'm glad I'll never have to read one of your indecisive, pass-the-buck, game reports.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by stick

With critics like you around that might not be possible.

Imagine the criticism you'd receive if you actually made this horrible call rather than just tried to find some justification for it.

[Camron Rust]

[QUOTE=stick;923986]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Personal? What was personal about what I said?

Explain what the intent of posting this was:

"You might as well claim he might have seen the defender punch him in the nose, pull his shorts down, and spit in his face."

Not personal, just pointing out the absurdity of the position you're taking.

And if you think that is personal, wow. You must have a tough time being an official.

Originally Posted by stick

Explain what the intent of posting this was

Camron didn't say anything personally attacking you. He just used a reductio ad absurdum argument against you. A fallacious argument maybe, but not personal.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by AremRed

Camron didn't say anything personally attacking you. He just used a reductio ad absurdum argument against you. A fallacious argument maybe, but not personal.

I'm glad I'm in an ethics class, so I halfway understand this.

[Adam]

This one is expired.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by AremRed

Camron didn't say anything personally attacking you. He just used a reductio ad absurdum argument against you. A fallacious argument maybe, but not personal.

Look at Mr. College making his smarty-pants observation.

(Edited to add: Whoops. Looks like I posted just after Adam closed the thread. Sorry, Adam. Let's end on me poking AremRed, k?)