Rsbq

[tref]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Again, maybe I'm seeing this differently than you, but if A1 isn't affected in the slightest, I don't see the point of calling a foul.

Quality, meaningful whistles... I Love It! We dont like GI Joe

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Sorry, but these are all just different ways of saying "advantage/disadvantage," which is just another way of wording 4-27-3.

Snaqs, you're exactly right, just another way of wording 4-27-3.
But the principles, if followed correctly, gives us a reference to make the correct call in different situations/areas on the court.
The guidelines are just that, guidelines.
Sometimes guidelines can be quite vague, the principles are more defined.
JMO

Originally Posted by rockyroad

...if he made no effort to straighten up, then B1 did not prevent him from standing upright within his "Cylinder of Verticality".

Sorta like the football official who calls an offensive hold, but the defender is standing right there allowing himself to be held.

Originally Posted by VaTerp

Gotcha.

I see it as the same concept applied to different situations but realize that, for whatever reason, not everybody sees it that way.

Give it another 2-5 seasons & they'll buy in! Especially once we get the RA in HS.