Three Firsts for a Newbie Last Nigh

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Thumper68

I was thinking of 4.44.3 sit. D, (b). Nothing made me think of traveling during the play in question.

1. Your partner may have thought of this play as an illegal dribble (which it used to be, and which more closely adheres to the wording and history of the rules).

2. Was he really arguing that this play was legal? IOW, even if you were thinking of it, was he? Since it in no way comes close to the play you had, how was this play even part of the argument? Was this what the coach thought happened?

3. When the coach offered to pull out the rule book, I would have informed him that the game (even half time) is not the place for this.