Continuous Motion/Gathering Ball

[CDurham]

Had a situation tonight in a JV Boys Game. I'm in the Lead position and A1 has the ball just inside the free throw line. He is dribbling parallel to the baseline and towards table side. He gathers the ball and goes up into the air. Where he was whacked. I went up with 2 shots. The coach of course wanted "on the floor" as he was dribbling towards the sideline. However, in my opinion he gathered the ball and started to turn in what I thought was a shooting motion. Sort of like a Kobe Bryant fade away.
- What do you guys see in this? Correct call?

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by CDurham

Had a situation tonight in a JV Boys Game. I'm in the Lead position and A1 has the ball just inside the free throw line. He is dribbling parallel to the baseline and towards table side. He gathers the ball and goes up into the air. Where he was whacked. I went up with 2 shots. The coach of course wanted "on the floor" as he was dribbling towards the sideline. However, in my opinion he gathered the ball and started to turn in what I thought was a shooting motion. Sort of like a Kobe Bryant fade away.
- What do you guys see in this? Correct call?

Good job. Shoot two free throws.

MTD, Sr.

[Loudwhistle]

Quote:
Originally Posted by CDurham View Post
Had a situation tonight in a JV Boys Game. I'm in the Lead position and A1 has the ball just inside the free throw line. He is dribbling parallel to the baseline and towards table side. He gathers the ball and goes up into the air. Where he was whacked. I went up with 2 shots. The coach of course wanted "on the floor" as he was dribbling towards the sideline. However, in my opinion he gathered the ball and started to turn in what I thought was a shooting motion. Sort of like a Kobe Bryant fade away.
- What do you guys see in this? Correct call?

From how it is described and how I picture it in my mind I would say you made the right call. It is different than the norm, but not uncommon especially with an advanced player, faking out an opponent is a great part of basketball. Sounds like he faked out the coach too by turning in air to shoot!

[Freddy]

Originally Posted by CDurham

. . . in my opinion he gathered the ball and started to turn in what I thought was a shooting motion.

Terms like "continuous motion" and "on the floor" cause confusion with what otherwise is very clear. And that is what you stated above, which merits two shots if his shooting motion did not result in a made basket.
We're depriving far too many their merited two free throws.
Banish from your officiating that term "on the floor."

[CDurham]

Originally Posted by Freddy

Terms like "continuous motion" and "on the floor" cause confusion with what otherwise is very clear. And that is what you stated above, which merits two shots if his shooting motion did not result in a made basket.
We're depriving far too many their merited two free throws.
Banish from your officiating that term "on the floor."

I say "before the shot" I used the term "on the floor" because the coach was arguing that there was motion in attempting a shot. What do you say?

[Freddy]

Originally Posted by CDurham

I say "before the shot" I used the term "on the floor" because the coach was arguing that there was motion in attempting a shot. What do you say?

"No Shot! Green ball out of bounds." (or ". . . one-and-one").

I like your "before the shot", also. Just not "On the Floor!"

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by CDurham

I say "before the shot" I used the term "on the floor" because the coach was arguing that there was motion in attempting a shot. What do you say?

"2 shots Coach"

[Jeremy Hohn]

Always use "NO SHOT" instead of "on the floor". My ruling is if they begin the "gather" to attempt the shot, I am lining them up. I believe it was a point of emphasis in the NCAA this season.

[Mark Padgett]

I yell, "Occurred prior to the starting of the continuous motion that usually leads to a shot".

Yeah, right.

[Adam]

Had a coach this year actually ask, "he can shoot from the floor?" He was questioning free throws on a foul that occurred low on the arms as the shooter was bringing the ball up off the floor to shoot in the paint.

Sadly, I couldn't help myself. "yes, it's called a set shot." Not proud of it, but he just walked away mumbling and let it go.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Jeremy Hohn

Always use "NO SHOT" instead of "on the floor".

Agree. If this little girl gets fouled in this position, I'm giving her two shots.

[Chess Ref]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Sadly, I couldn't help myself. "yes, it's called a set shot." Not proud of it, but he just walked away mumbling and let it go.

+1

I have a line for when I do something I know I shouldn't, but do it anyway.

"I'm so ashamed " ......stolen from Sara Jessica Parker in some dumb girl movie.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Chess Ref

+1

I have a line for when I do something I know I shouldn't, but do it anyway.

"I'm so ashamed " ......stolen from Sara Jessica Parker in some dumb girl movie.

"Lord I apologize...and be with the pygmies in New Guinea. Amen."

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Agree. If this little girl gets fouled in this position, I'm giving her two shots.

Billy:

I think her feet are behind the line, you better giver her three shots if she misses the shot.

MTD, Sr.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

Billy:

I think her feet are behind the line, you better giver her three shots if she misses the shot.

MTD, Sr.

For shooting outside the paint? You're generous (or is it chivalrous?)