Officiating Philosophy ?

[Coltdoggs]

Originally Posted by OHBBREF

this is pretty much how we call every game is it not?

This is what we do every game we set a tone and the players play to it. So why would you change that philosophy for any game?

Just making my case that perhaps during the FCP with a huge lead I no longer see the contact as incidental, that's all.

[Adam]

Here's how I do it.

If one team is clearly over matched, then they are likely less able to play through contact that could otherwise be incidental. If they can't play through it, it's more likely to be a foul.

But I'm not calling fouls for the sole purpose of teaching the winning coach a lesson.

[Coltdoggs]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Here's how I do it.

If one team is clearly over matched, then they are likely less able to play through contact that could otherwise be incidental. If they can't play through it, it's more likely to be a foul.

But I'm not calling fouls for the sole purpose of teaching the winning coach a lesson.

That's well put Snags...and really what I am thinking with my ideals on this matter. Is there a slight sense of "Hey a-hole...you're up by 25-30 points and still pressing..." sure...

[BBall_Junkie]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Here's how I do it.

If one team is clearly over matched, then they are likely less able to play through contact that could otherwise be incidental. If they can't play through it, it's more likely to be a foul.

But I'm not calling fouls for the sole purpose of teaching the winning coach a lesson.

Isn't this what I said on the previous page???

[Adam]

Originally Posted by BBall_Junkie

Isn't this what I said on the previous page???

well, then, I agree with the Junkie.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Coltdoggs

That's well put Snags...and really what I am thinking with my ideals on this matter. Is there a slight sense of "Hey a-hole...you're up by 25-30 points and still pressing..." sure...

Perhaps, but I try to avoid this; it really is a bias and one should try to avoid those on the court.

[eyezen]

Originally Posted by jdmara

For instance last week, I backed up to the coach and said, "Coach, it might be time to call off the dogs since you're up by 35." His response was, "Whoa thanks, I didn't even realize the score was that lopsided."

-Josh

First, it's not an official's place to say this to a coach, anytime, anywhere, any league.

Second, if you believe that BS I have a bridge in Brooklyn for sale.

[tomegun]

Rocky gave two examples of games where a team got blown out one week and blew a team out the next. Sometimes in sports, teams just get blown out and it has nothing to do with the officiating. To just look at a team pressing or whatever doesn't really give a clear picture of sportsmanship.

How about this?

How about applying that same awareness to the pursuit of the perfectly officiated game? I think that energy could be better spent someplace else. Sometimes teams are just that much better than the other team.

[tomegun]

Originally Posted by eyezen

First, it's not an official's place to say this to a coach, anytime, anywhere, any league.

Second, if you believe that BS I have a bridge in Brooklyn for sale.

+1

You shouldn't say this to a coach. You are opening up to many possibilities. What if a coach goes off and starts yelling, "Don't worry about how I coach my team, you can't tell me what plays to call!" Are you prepared to give the coach a T? Sometimes opening your mouth can cause you to really step in it.

[BillyMac]

Back in my coaching days, we were down by twenty points at halftime, and I asked the opposing coach to please continue to press us for at least the third period, so that we could continue to work on our press break. I informed the officials, and fans, about my request, so they wouldn't think the other coach was being unsporting. It helped us. The next time a team pressed us, we were ready.

[Brad]

Originally Posted by Kingsman1288

My intention is to get Team A out of the press and at least let Team B get the ball past half-court.

...

Was I wrong for doing this? Should I have let Team A continue to press the heck out of Team B?

Yes ... Your job is to referee the game. Just call it like it needs to be called and don't allow game/coaching philosophy to interfere with officiating philosophy.