Held ball stop clock

[LDUB]

Originally Posted by Nevadaref

Although trying to be helpful, I don't agree with the recommendation of your veteran partner. By widespread convention, the open palm signal is not just an indication to stop the clock, it conveys that the reason for doing so is that a violation has been committed. In the case of a held ball that is not true. Neither team has done anything wrong, so should the open palm signal be given?

First off fist up means stop clock for foul and open hand just means stop clock, not stop for violation. Secondly a held ball is a type of violation (I'm sure it says so in the Rules by Topic book, but not sure about the rule book.)

The only possible advantage of using the open hand up before signaling held ball is if another official is calling a foul. Hand up and fist up, get together and talk.