Need 2 Rulings!

[jkjenning]

Originally Posted by TRef21

1. I would say violation. If you saw this and the act was intentional, you should have whistled it a violation to prevent this from happening.

2. I would penalize player 1. Inital guarding position has be establised and a player may turn to absorb the contact. In this case I would give player 2 the benefit of the doubt and go offense.

Ditto if what you describe is objective. You could be casting the description in a way that biases the imagination. A charge can take place into a player's back, however, and the first sounds like an obvious violation.