Tip in at the buzzer

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

mplagrow:

Let me pose a rhetorical question: Why isn't this play a do over? The answer is NO, and here is why:

I've never seen such a lenghty answer to a "rhetorical question" and I've never seen the question "Why ..." answered, "No."

Furthermore, the descripton of the play does not tell us whether or not the game officials sounded their whistles when the game clock horn sounded.

And what if the whistle sounded before A2 touched the ball? Then, the location is still the original throw-in spot.