![]() |
|
|
|||
Denied Entry
Lets see if you think I got this right.
Following a time out and after the first warning horn I am counting the players on the court and can see 5 white team members and 4 red team members. Looking toward the red bench, I see a player standing on the court and the coach is looking at his elbow. Coach then says he has blood on him and I ask for a sub. At this point the white team coach sends a sub to the table. I allow the sub for the red team bleeder into the game, but deny entry to the white team sub because he presented himself after the warning horn. I know there is a rule that says if a player is required by rule to be replaced, then any other entry into the game may enter also, but I believe this applies only to free throws. Also I felt that the bleeding red player had never actually entered the game at this point, and his sub should be classified as the 5th red team member and not as a sub. Did I do it right by rule or not?
__________________
Failure is fertile ground on which to plant new seeds. |
|
|||
![]() Quote:
It is my reasoning that one of the purposes of having a game is to have the kids on the floor. Allowing White to substitute during this stoppage, or delay, has little difference to allowing a substitute in before the first of multiple free throws during an interim delay. |
|
|||
I allow the white team sub
I agree with Mick, and allow the sub. Another reason I can see is that white had a team on the floor based on what red had or didn't have on the floor. When red changes their team, it is only fair to allow white to "match up" by substituting. If the new red team player happens to be their offensive star, who was going to take a breather, then the white team should be allowed to sub in their defensive stopper who was on the bench for the same reason. IMHO
![]() |
|
|||
If I allow a player in for one team, then I allow players from both.
EDIT: Case play 3.3.1 SITUATION B: A time-out is granted to Team A with play to resume by administration of a free throw. A6 reports to enter after the timer's warning signal has sounded. Since A6 has reported too late to enter, could he/she enter if: (a) either team is granted a time-out; (b) the resumption of play is delayed because a player is injured getting into position for the free throw; or (c) Team A is willing to “buy” A6's way into the game with a technical foul? RULING: Permissible in (a) and (b), but not in (c).
__________________
"...as cool as the other side of the pillow." - Stuart Scott "You should never be proud of doing the right thing." - Dean Smith Last edited by BktBallRef; Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 10:19pm. |
|
||||
Quote:
3-3-6 . . . A player who is bleeding, has an open wound, has any amount of blood on his/her uniform, or has blood on his/her person, shall be directed to leave the game until the situation is corrected, unless a time-out is requested by, and granted to, his/her team and the situation can be corrected by the end of the time-out. 10-5-3 . . . The head coach must replace or remove a disqualified/injured player, or player directed to leave the game, within 30 seconds when a substitute is available, while within the confines of his/her bench. 2-12-5 . . . Sound a warning signal at 20 seconds of the 30 seconds (maximum) permitted for replacing a disqualified or injured player, or for a player directed to leave the game. And most likely this one too, despite the last part which would only apply if there was a player DQ: 2-8-4 . . . Notify the coach and request the timer to begin the replacement interval, and then notify the player on a disqualification. What exactly is this 30 seconds? It is a replacement interval, not a time-out. In 2003-04 the NFHS addressed this in a POE. POE #5 that year was called "Substituting – Player Disqualifications," and uses language specific to disqualified players or players who have "fouled out",but it can also logically be applied to any case in which a player is directed to leave the game and must be replaced in such time. That is the case here. Quote:
Did you instruct the timer to start a 30-second interval following the second horn from the time-out? Since you are asking if you did this right, I have to tell you that you didn't, if you failed to properly invoke the 30-second interval. Quote:
From the 2003-04 POE those are: H.If a substitute from the non-offending team or a substitute from the offending team for someone other than the disqualified player reports to the scorer during the wait for the required substitute, they may enter the game. (3-3-1d) (Notice that the rule citation given is not the FT exception.) I.A warning horn shall now be sounded at 20 seconds if the required substitute has not reported to the scorer’s table. This is an indication to the head coach that a substitute should report immediately (2-12-5). This warning horn does not have the same substitution restrictions as a warning horn for a time-out (3-3-1a); other substitutes from either team may still report and enter the game until the ball is about to become live. (3-3-2) Quote:
I don't agree with you there. The player with blood on him NEVER left the game, so he doesn't have to reenter at this point. He is already "actually entered." He is merely required by 10-1-9 to return to the floor at approximately the same time as the other four players. You said that he was on the court in front of the bench with his coach looking at his elbow, so he met that requirement. How can you say that the sub is not a "sub"? ![]() He is simply the required substitute for a bleeding player who was directed to leave the game following the time-out. That's my opinion on how the rules should be applied in this case. I truly do hope that my writing it out helps you in some way. ![]() |
|
|||
Quote:
Also, thanks for the option to accept or reject your post - Sometimes interpeting the rules is just like interpeting the law. Maybe we all need rules interpeters on retainer like companies do with lawyers.
__________________
Failure is fertile ground on which to plant new seeds. |
![]() |
Bookmarks |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
DH Re-entry | JL87 | Baseball | 8 | Wed Mar 19, 2003 12:30pm |
DH Re-entry | harmbu | Baseball | 3 | Tue Apr 30, 2002 02:34pm |
Protest Denied -- LL | NorCalBlue | Baseball | 16 | Sat Jul 14, 2001 12:05pm |
DH re-entry | PAblue87 | Baseball | 7 | Fri Apr 27, 2001 11:21pm |
Illegal Re-entry? | Sven | Basketball | 12 | Sat Jan 13, 2001 12:47pm |