For IAABO Eyes Only ...

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

I'm still waiting for an answer to a question about our Refresher Exam emailed a month ago.

Here's the answer in question.

It's a mechanics question and we use IAABO mechanics.

92) Indicating the throw-in spot is done by the administering official before placing ball at disposal of thrower.

My answer: Yes

Answer Sheet: No Page 45 Diagram (bottom)

“This box is set by the administering official before placing the ball at the disposal of thrower.”

So it’s a “box” not a “spot”?

But the actual rule definition says that it's a "spot".

Nowhere does the actual rule call it a "box".

4-42-6: The designated throw-in spot is 3 feet wide with no depth limitation and is established and signaled by the official prior to putting the ball at the thrower’s disposal.

Why am I wrong?

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Here's the answer in question.

It's a mechanics question and we use IAABO mechanics.

92) Indicating the throw-in spot is done by the administering official before placing ball at disposal of thrower.

My answer: Yes

Answer Sheet: No Page 45 Diagram (bottom)

“This box is set by the administering official before placing the ball at the disposal of thrower.”

So it’s a “box” not a “spot”?

But the actual rule definition says that it's a "spot".

Nowhere does the actual rule call it a "box".

4-42-6: The designated throw-in spot is 3 feet wide with no depth limitation and is established and signaled by the official prior to putting the ball at the thrower’s disposal.

Why am I wrong?

Billy:

You are correct. In fact Peter Webb like to remind people that it is not a Spot Throw-in but a Designated Spot Throw-in. Someone needs to drop a email to National and give them a piece of your mind and remind them of what Peter says.

MTD, Sr.

P.S. Thanks for the information you emailed me.

[joelpoli]

Billy,
I believe that the IAABO manual (and Peter Webb) tells us that the calling official indicates the throwin spot and the administrating official designates the spot.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

92) Indicating the throw-in spot is done by the administering official before placing ball at disposal of thrower.

My answer: Yes

Answer Sheet: No Page 45 Diagram (bottom)
“This box is set by the administering official before placing the ball at the disposal of thrower.”

So it’s a “box” not a “spot”?

But the actual rule definition says that it's a "spot".

Nowhere does the actual rule call it a "box".

4-42-6: The designated throw-in spot is 3 feet wide with no depth limitation and is established and signaled by the official prior to putting the ball at the thrower’s disposal.

Why am I wrong?

Originally Posted by joelpoli

I believe that the IAABO manual (and Peter Webb) tells us that the calling official indicates the throwin spot and the administrating official designates the spot.

Thanks for trying to explain.

Indicates versus designates.

The Manual actually says "sets".

Did I really deserve to get this wrong?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Did I really deserve to get this wrong?

Do you know the rule / mechanic? Then stop obsessing over this.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Do you know the rule / mechanic? Then stop obsessing over this.

Closest I ever came to a perfect exam.

I will probably never officiate a perfect game (who has?), but a perfect score on a written exam is possible, but after forty-four exams, time on the clock is quickly running down on me.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Closest I ever came to a perfect exam.

I only got two questions wrong. I know why I got #90 wrong.

90) Following time-out, the administering official shall announce jersey color, signal direction and signal the type of throw-in and then sound the whistle just before putting the ball at the disposal of the thrower.

My answer: Yes

Answer Sheet: No Page 42, Section F.1.g
“If following a timeout, intermission, or unusual delay, sound whistle, announce jersey color, signal direction, and signal the type of throwin.”

Question was out of order. Sound the whistle first. While I may disagree with that, that’s what it says in the IAABO Mechanics Manual, so I got it wrong.

I’m still trying to figure out why I got #92 (indicating the throw-in spot) wrong.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

92) Indicating the throw-in spot is done by the administering official before placing ball at disposal of thrower.

My answer: Yes

Answer Sheet: No Page 45 Diagram (bottom)

“This box is set by the administering official before placing the ball at the disposal of thrower.”

Originally Posted by BillyMac

I’m still trying to figure out why I got #92 wrong.

Originally Posted by joelpoli

I believe that the IAABO manual ... tells us that the calling official indicates the throwin spot and the administrating official designates the spot.

I've been told, from the IAABO International co-interpreters, via my local interpreter, that I confused the "ruling" official with "administering" official.

I still don't know why I got it wrong!

If I'm the administering official, I will indicate the throwin spot by either simply pointing to the spot, or by pointing to a spot and then signaling "run the endline".

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by joelpoli

Billy,
I believe that the IAABO manual (and Peter Webb) tells us that the calling official indicates the throwin spot and the administrating official designates the spot.

The "Calling" Official "indicates" where the Designated Spot Throw-in is, either: i) one of the four Designated Spots in a Team's Front Court or ii) the Designated Spot for all Designated Spot Throw-ins not subject to the Rule for (i).

The "Calling" Official is "indicating" to his Partners (especially to the "Administering" Official if the "Calling" Official will not be the "Administering" Official), Players, Coaches, Scorer, and Timer(s) as to where the Designated Spot for the Designated Spot Throw-in.

The "Administering" Official is "indicating" to the Thrower where the Designated Spot for the Throw-in is.

As I stated earlier to you Billy, your answer is correct because both the "Calling" Official and the "Administering" Official are to do it but for different reasons.

This is a "gotcha" question which has two correct answers.

MTD, Sr.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

This is a "gotcha" question which has two correct answers.