Survey Says ...

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by RefRich

If the coach answers no then you say, they better be before the start of the game or we’ll have a technical to start the game. If the coach doesn’t know it’s his fault.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

So the question has absolutely nothing to do with enforcement. The players are either legally equipped or not, and how or if the coach answers the question has no bearing on the punishment.


Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

[LRZ]

Originally Posted by Raymond

So the question has absolutely nothing to do with enforcement. The players are either legally equipped or not, and how or if the coach answers the question has no bearing on the punishment.

Raymond, you are correct. In PA, we are required to ask the question as part of our mandatory pre-game captains/coaches meeting. The perfunctory answer has always been yes; I've never had a coach say no.

And there is no linkage between an incorrect answer and the ruling when a player is illegally uniformed. The "punishment" is based on the illegality itself, not on the coach's earlier, erroneous reply to the question.

[RefRich]

Originally Posted by Raymond

So the question has absolutely nothing to do with enforcement. The players are either legally equipped or not, and how or if the coach answers the question has no bearing on the punishment.


Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

No argument with that and I don't believe asking the question is even needed. Ether they are or they aren't and that question will not correct the behavior.

[BryanV21]

Originally Posted by RefRich

No argument with that and I don't believe asking the question is even needed. Ether they are or they aren't and that question will not correct the behavior.

Can't you equate that to checking the book at around 12 minutes to give time to correct any mistakes? Even if you don't check early, just like not asking about the legality of the uniforms, the penalty is the same.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BryanV21

Can't you equate that to checking the book at around 12 minutes to give time to correct any mistakes? Even if you don't check early, just like not asking about the legality of the uniforms, the penalty is the same.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

It would be the equivalent if we were checking the uniforms instead of asking about them. We don't check the book by asking the coach if his roster has been correctly entered into the scorebook and if the starters are marked.

[BryanV21]

Originally Posted by Raymond

It would be the equivalent if were checking the uniforms instead of asking about them.

Fine. But the point is the same... It's not a bad idea to be proactive.

Honestly, I personally don't even ask anymore. But I'm not going to come down on those that do or work in places where it's required.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BryanV21

Fine. But the point is the same... It's not a bad idea to be proactive.

Honestly, I personally don't even ask anymore. But I'm not going to come down on those that do or work in places where it's required.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

I'm coming down on the state, not the officials. We don't know if players are properly equipped until we visually inspect the players. Asking a coach doesn't change or influence the enforcement. And the only technical fouls are for illegal numbers and not wearing white@home/dark@road. So if his team is wearing a bunch of illegal t-shirts the only penalty is they can't participate until they remove the t-shirts.

Originally Posted by Raymond

Asking a coach doesn't change or influence the enforcement.

Unfortunately a lot of officials in my state think that if we don't ask, we can't enforce.

Of course they believe a lot of other things too. Like how referees are 'supposed' to stay opposite the table during the national anthem, lineups, etc. Which the mechanics manual alludes to during the pre-game warmup, but does not specify where officials should stand after the warmup.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by RefRich

No argument with that and I don't believe asking the question is even needed. Ether they are or they aren't and that question will not correct the behavior.

True, if all we're talking about is, say, illegal numbers or something.

But, and this might be more true in other sports (the states / FED aren't going to have the question only for some sports and not for others), if someone is wearing / using something illegal and someone gets hurt by that illegal item, having asked the question can be part of a defense.