Wrong Number

[bob jenkins]

I don't really understand the confusion. It's penalized when it occurs (vs. "before the ball becomes live to start the game" or "when discovered" as in the other subsections), but it's only penalized once.

Note that if the book just changed A7's number and A7 entered and the ball became live, it's too late to penalize A7. Now, when A9 tries the same stunt, you can penalize for that.

[Valley Man]

Thanks Freddie .. that is how I wanted to go just needed that push.

[Valley Man]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Note that if the book just changed A7's number and A7 entered and the ball became live, it's too late to penalize A7. Now, when A9 tries the same stunt, you can penalize for that.

OK .. what if your table didnt change the number for A7 and the tell you next dead ball. Still too late to penalize?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Valley Man

OK .. what if your table didnt change the number for A7 and the tell you next dead ball. Still too late to penalize?

What's the penalty for? Is it for "playing with an incorrect number" or for "changing the book?" That will (help) answer your question.

See also cases 3.2.2A and 3.2.2C

[Valley Man]

Thanks Bob