interesting run down situation

[johnnyg08]

I'm surprised that this thread has gone three pages.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

I'm surprised that this thread has gone three pages.

It only takes one person to not see the light for a thread to drag on.

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

It only takes one person to not see the light for a thread to drag on.

And who died and bestowed the title "Rule Guru's" upon you two. You had every oppurtunity to pipe in with your brillance at any time. Oh I know, your above that.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by jicecone

And who died and bestowed the title "Rule Guru's" upon you two. You had every oppurtunity to pipe in with your brillance at any time. Oh I know, your above that.

Being a rules guru is what bestowed that title on him.

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

Being a rules guru is what bestowed that title on him.

Maybe so, but being rude is uncalled for.

[bob jenkins]

My comment was meant generically, and not directed specifically at anyone in this thread.

I have posted suggested forum (software) rules that IMO would help.

And, I did post support for the correct answer back in post #13.

To be clear:

If 2 (or more) runners are on a base and tagged, the runner entitled to the base is safe and the other runner(s) is(are) out.

If 1 runner is on a base and tagged, he's safe, unless he's been forced from the base (not applicable in this play).

None of the other rule book mastication matters.