Catcher covering third base

[UmpJM]

Originally Posted by Rich Ives

The thing we can't tell from just looking is whether the catcher's "repositioning" as you call it was really an attempt to get up but something hurt and he couldn't. So, uppon watching the video, we have expressed different viewpoints and neither of us knows which is really correct - or whether there's some third thing.

Rich,

I believe I completely agree with your point.

The best and most compelling argument against the use of video replay, IMO.

JM