Double Play or Not?

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by NFump

OBS/INT or none?

This is what we've been arguing all along. The first part of YOUR post(linked above) is what the original question was about and what we've been saying the whole time.
That is how we got the double play. Accidental live ball, play on runner out if tagged while off base. Intent on the part of either player kill it and rule accordingly.

This is what I said (in this other thread you have referenced):

Let me be crystal clear:

If F6 clearly accidentally knocks a runner who is not even paying attention off the base, then that runner is liable to be called out if tagged. Nobody is disputing this.

If F6 clearly intentionally knocks a runner off the base, the runner is not liable to be called out. Nobody is disputing this.

Argument over.

What part of that is wrong or unclear?

I contend that the OP didn't state whether or not it was intentional, but that is the way it reads to me. Without any further information, it is the most logical scenario. Intentional, for reasons I've already stated.