Double Play or Not?

[umpjong]

Originally Posted by mbyron

Thanks. Still not relevant though: the OP is about F6 fielding a batted ball, not playing on a runner with a "hard slap tag" or "pushing him off base."

I'm not sure why you repeatedly decline to see the difference: in the OP the fielder is protected, in your case, he isn't.

But go ahead and keep saying, "it's just like this other case with a different ruling," and rule on it as you wish. It's your choice to remain invincibly ignorant.

You know I have been more than civil, it seems that you are the one who does not want to face reality. You have shown nothing in regards to your application of the rules, which shows why you probably will continue to work lower levels.
And you refuse to accept that none of the written examples and interpretations distinguishes between your absurd notion that there is a difference between a fielder knocking a runner off a base making a play or not. Please read the article in total without blinders on and you might actually learn something. I'm actually tired of your incompetence.