Catcher signal to manager - How do you deal?

[TussAgee11]

I wasn't upset that he did it at all. In my conversation I showed no emotion and did not tell him to knock it off.

My goal, being a rookie to this league (and hence, in their minds, a rookie no matter how many games I've done), was to let the catcher know that I know what's going on and I wasn't an idiot back there. I figured it was a non-confrontational way to solidify myself back there, rather than not saying anything, manager eventually starting in, and me having to deal with it that way.

Any of that make sense? Should I be worried about solidifying my rep. as to minimize potential problems later? What are some other ways I can do this, if this way wasn't a good spot?

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by TussAgee11

Any of that make sense? Should I be worried about solidifying my rep. as to minimize potential problems later? What are some other ways I can do this, if this way wasn't a good spot?

I think that you understand that there's an adjustment period for new umpires to adult leagues. One suggestion I would make is to let the catchers know at the beginning of the game that you're open to communication.

I will sometimes say, after introducing myself: "If you think that I'm consistently missing a pitch, please let me know between innings." This approach lets them know that I'm open to discussion, provided that it's discreet.

[GA Umpire]

Originally Posted by TussAgee11

Any of that make sense? Should I be worried about solidifying my rep. as to minimize potential problems later? What are some other ways I can do this, if this way wasn't a good spot?

1)Understood what you were trying to do.
2)No.
3)Call your game the best you can and they will learn what you will and won't call. Also, EJ when necessary and this will solidify them knowing what they can and can't do. Don't worry about what they are signaling/not signaling. Act like you don't even see it. If you get caught up with that little bit, you will miss something even bigger. Forget about it.

[Rcichon]

Originally Posted by TussAgee11

... What are some other ways I can do this, if this way wasn't a good spot?

Be consistent. F2 was just communicating where the pitch was or where he wants it.

By the way, be consistent.





Did I mention, "be consistent"?

[Maz17]

Wear a leather umpire shirt... your skin is way to thin!

[David B]

Originally Posted by ozzy6900

My opinion is similar to F1 taking signs. How in the heck do I know what tapping the shin guard means? For all you know, this "signal" could be anything from communication to a tick - you have no idea!

In short, leave it alone until someone actually comes to you and agrues balls & strikes. Then you can do something about it.

Exactly, who care what F2 thought about the pitch. Even with college kids a lot of them still don't know the zone - just watch some of the CWS.

Now some times early in a game if F2 starts yapping "good pitch" I might tell him, "no that's low" or "that's not a strike" just to help him know what the zone is for "today".

Thanks
David

[DG]

Originally Posted by TussAgee11

Doing the best summer baseball around here, full of kids who play college ball or older guys who never made it out of A or AA.

Here's the sitch - a close pitch that I called ball. Catcher was calling his own game. He throws the ball back, looks into the dugout, and subtly slaps his shin guard.

Obviously, he's letting the manager know what he thought of the pitch.

How would you deal with this?

I would make note of it and that is all. Maybe you blew the pitch, sh*t happens you know. Watch the batter's reaction too. If he looks surprised then that is feedback also. As long as they are not chirpping about calls I could care less what they do, unless I am missing strikes and I hate when that happens.

[constable]

I wouldn't have said a thing. There is a decent chance that signal could be a critque of your call. There is also a good chance he could be telling his infielders to shift or something like that.

I used to catch. I'd routinely adjust my gear for no reason.

Personally, I'd let it go. Don't umpire through a microscope.

[Pensaump]

Originally Posted by TussAgee11

Me: "Does tapping your leg mean good call or bad call?"
F2: "Huh?"
Me: "On that close pitch, you letting your manager know what you thought?"
F2: "Just communicating"
Me: "Ok"

Critiques?

Don't go hunting...

Be cool