Another Balk Question

[Ump29]

Under OBR the result would be the same (R2 at 3rd and BR with same count) as both BR and and any other runners did not advance at least 1 base on the pitch after the balk.

[soundedlikeastrike]

"Never heard anything from the OC questioning the movement of his players."

Heck no, now his .097 hitting, # 9 guy, is on 1B, instead of & 2 strikes.

OBR, had R2 advanced "on the throw", I'd a left em R3, R1.

Does NCAA stay live?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by soundedlikeastrike

"Never heard anything from the OC questioning the movement of his players."

Heck no, now his .097 hitting, # 9 guy, is on 1B, instead of & 2 strikes.

OBR, had R2 advanced "on the throw", I'd a left em R3, R1

That would be correct becuase everyone advanced at least one base on the play.

Does NCAA stay live?

This NCAA rule is the same as the OBR rule

[RPatrino]

FED is the only code where a balk is an automatic dead ball. Makes things interesting for those of us who work the other codes as well.

[johnnyg08]

FED is simple, as other posters have said...if you have a balk...everything stops period.

[SanDiegoSteve]

I had originally misread the OP, and incorrectly answered the question concerning OBR. I thought that the BR did not advance at least one base.

[johnnyg08]

so in this sitch, since the BR reaches but R2 doesn't advance at least one base...do you keep the BR @ 1B,then move R2 to 3b...?? OBR/NCAA interp