How do you deal with counseling/critiquing newer umps?

[lawump]

What I do as my Association's President and what I do as "only" an umpire is this.

As Association President: I do evaluations and my evaluations are blunt...but I try to point out what they are doing well as what needs improvement.

As an "umpire" (that is when I was not President): I critique only if asked by the umpire. But if I am asked, I am honest. I do not volunteer information.