Foul Ball Called in Error

[DG]

Originally Posted by NY87

Those comments and questions were directed to my partner. That was just about the moment he probably realized: oops - why did I call that foul?

The overwhelming consensus has been, admit the mistake.

In this particular game, I was the senior umpire; my partner is new to the association. If you were in a similar situation, do you advise the newbie to admit his goof, or let him figure it out on his own?

A new question. You are the senior guy and the new PU comes to you for help. you should first discuss the play. Ask him what he saw and heard and explain what you think the correct ruling is and that based on what he has told you the correct ruling is not "Foul", but it is a call that will have to stand. And, that he will need to explain to the coach complaining that he made a mistake, and the call can't be reversed. If he wants your help then walk over with him to the coach for the explanation, but he will need to do the explaining and you should only speak if the coach does not want to accept the explanation.

I expect the explanation will go well and the coach will accept it but if the coach becomes personal, profane or prolonged you may have to advise your new umpire it is time toss this guy.