Obstruction on last play of inning

[Little Jimmy]

This happened today and I wondered what the mechanics would be if it was twisted slightly. Utrip tourney but I don't think it makes a difference. R1 on 2nd. R2 on 1st. 2 outs. B1 hits a gapper. As R1 rounds third she is obstructed by F5 (I signal) and she continues toward home. Then R2 to tries to stretch her advance to 3rd. She is thrown out for the 3rd out of the inning, but plate ump says runner just crossed the plate before the out, run counts. All is hunky dory.

But what if R1 didn't score before the 3rd out? She was obstructed. Simply announce the obstruction, award home, and count the out at third as the third out of the inning?

This is probably straightforward, but just wondering.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Little Jimmy

This happened today and I wondered what the mechanics would be if it was twisted slightly. Utrip tourney but I don't think it makes a difference. R1 on 2nd. R2 on 1st. 2 outs. B1 hits a gapper. As R1 rounds third she is obstructed by F5 (I signal) and she continues toward home. Then R2 to tries to stretch her advance to 3rd. She is thrown out for the 3rd out of the inning, but plate ump says runner just crossed the plate before the out, run counts. All is hunky dory.

But what if R1 didn't score before the 3rd out? She was obstructed. Simply announce the obstruction, award home, and count the out at third as the third out of the inning?

This is probably straightforward, but just wondering.

I think you are saying that ITUJ R1 did not reach home in time because of the OBS. Then, probably what you said.
Otherwise, the OBS means nothing.

[youngump]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

I think you are saying that ITUJ R1 did not reach home in time because of the OBS. Then, probably what you said.
Otherwise, the OBS means nothing.

I agree with you and would call it that way. I think if I called it this way (have never seen it happen), I'd be backed up around here. But is this at all justifiable given the rules?

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by Little Jimmy

This happened today and I wondered what the mechanics would be if it was twisted slightly. Utrip tourney but I don't think it makes a difference. R1 on 2nd. R2 on 1st. 2 outs. B1 hits a gapper. As R1 rounds third she is obstructed by F5 (I signal) and she continues toward home. Then R2 to tries to stretch her advance to 3rd. She is thrown out for the 3rd out of the inning, but plate ump says runner just crossed the plate before the out, run counts. All is hunky dory.

But what if R1 didn't score before the 3rd out? She was obstructed. Simply announce the obstruction, award home, and count the out at third as the third out of the inning?

This is probably straightforward, but just wondering.

Speaking what I believe would be in most assn., the idea of an OBS call is to negate the impediment of the runner. If in your judgment, the OBS prevented the runner from reaching the plate safely prior to the execution of the 3rd out, the run should be allowed to score.