mechanics again

[Stat-Man]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

This came up because of a trapped line drive which all the players thought was caught.

ASA has a signal for a trapped ball in the signal chart from a couple of years ago (signalling safe and verbalizing "trapped ball").

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by Stat-Man

ASA has a signal for a trapped ball in the signal chart from a couple of years ago (signalling safe and verbalizing "trapped ball").

Since ASA specifically deleted the word "trap" or "trapped" since it is either a "catch" or "no catch," I hope they removed or amended that chart to maintain consistency.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

I was instructed to signal safe on any no-catch of an uncaught batted fly ball; although using the fair signal for those near the line.

This came up because of a trapped line drive which all the players thought was caught.

Opinions, confirmations, corrections ???

I think the consensus is that this is correct.
Thanks to those who responded.

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

I think the consensus is that this is correct.
Thanks to those who responded.

Who is teaching that? Signal every uncaught fly ball? Shall we do that on grounders in the infield too?

[xtremeump]

Where is the "Adjusting your cup" in the book ? If it is not there what do you do ? Watching a good MLB Crew, it looks so simple, doing an NCAA game you need to be in the game and not worry about a Foul Ball, get the F1 a ball, she is waiting for it. Work Smarter not Harder.

[CecilOne]

Starting in "C", R1 on 2nd, ball hit to SS, looks at 1st, then spins and throws to 3rd. If you stepped toward 1st to make the call, you are then straight lined by the runner, maybe also blocked by the SS. Do you have a preferred/taught solution to seeing the play?

[Steve M]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

Starting in "C", R1 on 2nd, ball hit to SS, looks at 1st, then spins and throws to 3rd. If you stepped toward 1st to make the call, you are then straight lined by the runner, maybe also blocked by the SS. Do you have a preferred/taught solution to seeing the play?

yes - delay that first step & let fielder tell you where play is. And know that if the coach really wanted somebody on top of the call, they'd have 3 umpires.

[Manny A]

Originally Posted by Steve M

yes - delay that first step & let fielder tell you where play is. And know that if the coach really wanted somebody on top of the call, they'd have 3 umpires.

Agree.

You should also be a student of the game and realize that with R1 at second and a ball hit to F6, R1 has no business running to third (unless she's forced by an R2 at first), and if she does, then the likely play with less than two outs is going to be at third base. Don't overanticipate and expect the play to go to first.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Steve M

yes - delay that first step & let fielder tell you where play is. And know that if the coach really wanted somebody on top of the call, they'd have 3 umpires.

I get that, but I was talking about fielder motioning as if to 1st, after fielding.

Originally Posted by Manny A

Agree.

You should also be a student of the game and realize that with R1 at second and a ball hit to F6, R1 has no business running to third (unless she's forced by an R2 at first), and if she does, then the likely play with less than two outs is going to be at third base. Don't overanticipate and expect the play to go to first.

Yes it has to be a force, forgot to say R2.

I was looking for a solution for after the SS motions to 1st, "then spins and throws to 3rd". Do you think continuing inward or trying to get back out to avoid the straight line?

[Andy]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

...

I was looking for a solution for after the SS motions to 1st, "then spins and throws to 3rd". Do you think continuing inward or trying to get back out to avoid the straight line?

Let the ball take you to the play. Don't move until the ball is on the way.

If F6 does throw to first, you are only going to get one or two steps, but you are already at a crappy angle and getting closer to the play doesn't really help.

By waiting, you allow yourself the opportunity to get a decent look and angle if R1 takes off for third and the throw goes there. Since third base is a lot closer to home than first base, it's a higher priority to make sure we can get a good look at any play there.