Question on ASA RS #33

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by Manny A

Because rule books are notorious for using conflicting language, leaving out vital information, being outright wrong, etc. etc. etc.

(Edited to add) So, I take it from your response that the runner is not out, since it doesn't say?

And if a BR goes from the plate, then 3rd, 2nd & 1st and finally home, you are going to allow a run to score because the book doesn't demand a specific order?

While I agree some language seems conflicting, IMO, it is more likely that many issues people have is that rules do not expressly address every little possible scenario and "what if" situations.

If a Senior team shows up at a Men's E state tournament and only have bats approved only for senior softball, do you allow them to play with those bats because they are a Senior team? Do the rules address specifically address that?

If a plane crashes in an adjacent field, do you rule "no pitch"?

And, yes, it is heading to absurdity, but IMO so was your question since your answer is in the first three words of your citation.