Unrep Sub: Say Something or Stay Mum?

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by rwest

There are plenty of rule violations, (and going back to touch a base they are not entitled to is a rules violation), that we don't rule on until requested to. ...

We don't rule on that ever. The violation we rule on is missing the base / leaving the base early in the first place, not the return when they weren't entitled to. As said, above, it is better to look at this return as moot rather than illegal. We all know we can't read the rule book like Holy Writ. Even though the book would seem to declare this return as "illegal", what the rule is really saying is the action will not correct the leaving early violation.