HS SB Incident Report

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by mbcrowder

Base umpire needs some serious remedial umpiring classes. He was the most egregious offender here.

1) Do NOT join a conference between your partner and a coach until asked.
2) When asked, your conference with your partner should be AWAY from any coaches and unhearable by coaches.
3) Learn what a foul ball is and what the ball has to hit FIRST to become one, and then learn what a HBP is, and understand how those definitions do not overlap. Ever.

Plate umpire needs to learn where the line is. He crossed it when talking to Head Coach. Then he utterly failed to properly act when assistant coach crossed it (repeatedly). The commentary while warming up the pitcher should have been abruptly cut off about 5 words in. Also - don't say "That's enough" unless it IS enough... if you're going to let them keep going, it wasn't enough. Continuing after "That's enough" should be an ejection.

Lastly, the attitude of "I hated to eject him" tells me he's not doing his job. Coaches eject themselves, we merely announce it. He's just made life harder on every umpire that follows him.

+1

I agree completely, BU needs some wall to wall counseling on rules and game management. The good is the PU acknowledged he shouldn't have engaged in that discussion with the HC the way he did. I believe he should be counseled to stand firm with a coach when a warning is given, especially with an assistant.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Yep, partner should have kept his mouth shut.

And the discussion lasted longer than it should have, but it was the coach who raised the financial opportunity and I don't know if I could have walked away from that one. I could use the money.

AFA the Asst. Coach, maybe the ejection was too light. I would have been tempted to call the HC over and give him the option: AC is ejected, or the AC can take that rule book to the parking lot and when he finds the rule which states a HBP on a swing and a miss is a foul ball, he can once again enter the field on which I am umpiring.

May never see that guy again