proper position on passed ball

[shipwreck]

What is your preferred position to be in when you are PU and there is a passed ball that goes to the backstop and richochets more to the third base side and a runner is coming home? I always liked to circle inside the diamond and get a 90 there but a friend of mine said it is too easy for the pitcher to block your view from there. If I stay outside toward the normal calling area, it seems like I am in harms way of the throw. Third base extended wouldn't give me the best look either because also of being possibly blocked, poor depth perception and no 90. Any thoughts? Dave

[SC Ump]

Originally Posted by shipwreck

Third base extended wouldn't give me the best look ...

If the ball is somewhere near first base extended and the pitcher will probably be right in front of the plate, then I think third base extended would be a good 90º mark from where the ball will be coming and from where the tag will be applied.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by shipwreck

What is your preferred position to be in when you are PU and there is a passed ball that goes to the backstop and richochets more to the third base side and a runner is coming home? I always liked to circle inside the diamond and get a 90 there but a friend of mine said it is too easy for the pitcher to block your view from there. If I stay outside toward the normal calling area, it seems like I am in harms way of the throw. Third base extended wouldn't give me the best look either because also of being possibly blocked, poor depth perception and no 90. Any thoughts? Dave

There is no proper predefined position. 3BE isn't bad if the fielder taking the throw which may not always be F1 remains on the infield side of the plate to receive the ball. However, if they move to block the runner, you will not see the play and that action by the fielder may not occur until the throw is received.

I would think your best bet would be moving to the front of the LHBB as a starting point and adjusting your position based on the defender's location to the plate if the ball is behind the plate on the 3B side. However, the more the ball moves up the 3b line, the more likely it is you will get a good look if you stay toward the back of the RHBB and adjust to the line of the throw.

But these are possibilities we can toss around all day. When this occurs, you are going to have about one second to decide which way to move and there are so many variables (avoiding the catcher, finding the ball, runner's approach, covering defender, location of the batter) involved, I don't think anyone can provide you with a "given" mechanic for such a play.

[DaveASA/FED]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

When this occurs, you are going to have about one second to decide which way to move and there are so many variables (avoiding the catcher, finding the ball, runner's approach, covering defender, location of the batter) involved, I don't think anyone can provide you with a "given" mechanic for such a play.

Sure they can, it is as follows:
Be where you need to be in order to see the play, as close to 90 degrees to the tag as possible, without getting in the way of the throw, runner or covering defender.

See that was easy, and it will work for every scenario!

[CajunNewBlue]

Originally Posted by DaveASA/FED

Sure they can, it is as follows:
Be where you need to be in order to see the play,

wonder if i have time to run around into the stands?.... thats the best view!!

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

wonder if i have time to run around into the stands?.... thats the best view!!

Nah... Dugouts or outfield. See signature.